Understanding Addiction: The “Nature vs. Nurture” Debate


If you’re struggling with addiction, you may be wondering, “Why do I do this? Why do I continue to hurt myself and others by taking the first drink, pill, or hit?” 


You’re not alone—addiction is a baffling disease. The Big Book of Alcoholics Anonymous, a classic text in the recovery world, says, “The truth…is usually that [the addict or alcoholic] has no more idea why he took that first drink than you have.” 


Through extensive work with our clients, our team at The Ohana has gained deep insights into addiction as a complex interplay of genetic predisposition and environmental factors. In this article, we’ll take a deep dive into the “nature versus nurture” debate, providing perspectives rarely heard outside the treatment world. 

Understanding Addiction: The “Nature vs. Nurture” Debate

The Genetic Component of Addiction: “Nature”

Here’s what we know about the ways your genes impact your propensity for addiction:


  1. Genetic Predisposition

Certain individuals inherit genes that make them more susceptible to addiction. This doesn’t mean they will definitely develop an addiction, but they have a higher risk compared to the general population. Research has identified several genes that can influence addiction risk. These genes often relate to the functioning of neurotransmitters like dopamine and serotonin, which are crucial for the brain’s reward system.


Variations in metabolism can also play a role. Genetic differences can affect how a person’s body processes substances. For example, some people might metabolize alcohol differently, leading to a higher risk of developing alcoholism.


  1. Heritability

Twin and adoption studies have been crucial in understanding the heritability of addiction. Identical twins (who share all their genes) show higher concordance rates for addiction compared to fraternal twins (who share about 50% of their genes), indicating a significant genetic component.


  1. Interaction with Neurobiology

Genetics can influence how brain reward systems function, affecting how pleasure and rewards are perceived and processed. This can make some individuals more likely to seek out addictive substances or behaviors as a source of pleasure.


Genetic factors can also determine how sensitive a person is to the effects of a substance. Some may experience more intense effects, which could lead to a higher likelihood of continued use and eventual addiction.


  1. Epigenetics

Epigenetics refers to changes in gene expression that are caused by environmental factors. While someone may have a genetic predisposition to addiction, environmental factors often play a critical role in whether this potential is realized. A person with a genetic risk may never develop addiction if they are not exposed to certain environmental triggers like high stress, trauma, or access to addictive substances.

Environmental Influences: “Nurture”

Genetics alone doesn’t tell the whole story, and while it’s important to understand the inherited elements of addiction, there’s not much we can always do about them. 


Environmental factors like the below are equally pivotal in shaping addiction, and they may be even more crucial to understand because they can be changed.


  1. Early Life Experiences

Experiences of abuse, neglect, or trauma during childhood significantly increase the risk of addiction later in life. These experiences can lead to psychological distress, which may be coped with through substance use. Additionally, the presence of addiction in the family, parental attitudes towards substance use, and overall family dynamics can shape an individual’s attitude towards drugs and alcohol.


  1. Social and Peer Influences

The influence of peers, especially during adolescence, can be a strong factor in initial substance experimentation and continued use. Cultural norms regarding substance use, and how substances are portrayed in media and in a community, can impact the likelihood of substance abuse. 


  1. Exposure to Substances

Not surprisingly, easy access to drugs or alcohol increases the risk of experimentation and eventual addiction.


  1. Stress and Coping Mechanisms

High levels of stress, whether from work, relationships, financial pressures, or other life circumstances, can lead individuals to turn to substances as a coping mechanism. Lack of healthy coping strategies for dealing with stress or emotional pain can make people more susceptible to wanting an “escape.”


  1. Socioeconomic Factors

Poverty and economic hardship can contribute to higher levels of stress and decreased access to healthcare, including mental health services, potentially leading to substance abuse. Lower levels of education and unemployment are also linked to increased risk of substance abuse, often due to associated stress and lack of opportunities for constructive engagement.


  1. Trauma and Life Events

Experiences of trauma in adulthood, including military combat, violent assault, or severe accidents, can increase the likelihood of substance abuse as a form of coping. Major life changes or losses, such as the death of a loved one, divorce, or job loss, can also trigger substance abuse in individuals seeking relief from emotional pain.


  1. Environmental Stressors

Living in an environment with high crime rates, violence, and substance availability, as well as a lack of supportive relationships and social isolation, can increase the risk of addiction.


  1. Healthcare Access and Quality

Limited access to quality treatment for substance abuse and mental health issues can exacerbate the problem, making recovery more difficult. 


  1. Social and Institutional Factors

Stigma surrounding addiction can prevent individuals from seeking help, while discrimination based on race, gender, or social status can increase stress and isolation. Government policies and law enforcement practices regarding drugs can also influence addiction rates, either by restricting access, providing treatment and rehabilitation, or through punitive measures.


Understanding these environmental influences is crucial for developing comprehensive prevention and treatment strategies that address the varied and complex needs of those struggling with addiction.

A woman discussing addiction treatments

Interplay of Nature and Nurture

Ultimately, addiction isn’t just about nature OR nurture—it’s influenced by both. Our experience at The Ohana Treatment Center shows that genetics and environment interact in complex ways. A genetic predisposition may increase risk, but environmental factors often activate the development of addiction. Conversely, a person without genetic risk factors might still develop addiction due to negative environmental influences.

Addiction treatment at The Ohana

Nature and Nurture at The Ohana

Recognizing the dual role of genetics and environment, our treatment philosophy is holistic, meaning we treat the whole person. We emphasize understanding each person’s unique environmental background, including family dynamics, cultural influences, and personal experiences with trauma, all of which significantly impact the likelihood of addiction. Our programs include cognitive-behavioral therapy, family therapy, mindfulness, and experiential therapies, combined with a focus on physical health through nutrition and fitness.


Prevention and education are also critical in our approach to tackling addiction. By educating about both genetic and environmental aspects, we aim to reduce stigma and foster understanding. 


Addiction is a multifaceted issue, not solely the result of nature or nurture but an intricate interaction of both. At The Ohana, we embrace this complexity with comprehensive, personalized care that addresses both genetic and environmental factors. Our treatment plans are tailored to each client, ensuring the most effective treatment for their specific situation. Our ultimate goal? Helping you find lasting freedom from addiction.


More to explorer

The Ohana Hawaii

The Ohana Hawaii

Thank you For Contacting Us!

An agent will be contacting you shortly to further discuss your treatment options! Thanks for choosing The Ohana Hawaii!

Verify Your Insurance

    After pressing the submit button below, please wait up to one minute for your insurance data to be securely transmitted.